What Does a Creative Director Actually Do and How Might it Change? Part 2/4

The Competitive Survey as a Creative Act

Research is an opportunity to learn, become inspired, and understand the category in which the product lives. I relish the practice of diving deeply into the competitive landscape of a particular industry. Traveling to Basel, Switzerland, for the International Watch Show, in one short week I’m able to survey the luxury watch industry and gauge the positioning of each brand. Rather than traveling to NYC, Tokyo, Paris, Milan, London, and Dubai, I can see the field. Similarly for jewelry, the Las Vegas JCK and luxury shows are a broad swath of global brands and directions.

Surveying the competitive landscape is essential to revealing opportunity. Understanding how every brand is positioned makes it possible to see white spaces left behind by the collective field. Finding that empty square on the chessboard is in itself a creative act. You can only find it by knowing which squares are already occupied. Once you understand the landscape, you can begin to cut gently against it to find opportunities.

Working Across Industries

In two decades working in the worlds of cosmetics, jewelry, fashion, spirits, wellness and technology, every industry has its own language, best practices, and idiosyncrasies to be studied and internalized. As an external creative director (rather than in-house), my clients in different industries offer me knowledge and fluency across categories and disciplines.

For example, I have identified trends in jewelry packaging; applying those to the cosmetics industry is innovative and interesting. Similarly, lessons from fashion photography may influence a wellness company, a successful color story owned by a spirit brand may translate seamlessly into a tech brand. Many positioning ideas have revealed themselves to me at such intersections, ideas migrating from one field to another.

A great example of cross-pollination is MAC Cosmetics. At a time when the cosmetics industry was defined by bright, daytime happiness, MAC positioned itself as a nighttime, gender-fluid brand, thereby disrupting the category. Such positioning had already proven successful for Bacardi, owning the night in the spirits category.

A powerful position occupied in one industry may be completely open in another.

Previous
Previous

What Does a Creative Director Actually Do and How Might it Change? Part 3/4

Next
Next

What Does a Creative Director Actually Do and How Might it Change? Part 1/4